Use of a Black-Tailed Prairie Dog Burrow by Honey Bees in the Texas Panhandle
James D. Ray1,2,* and Todd Mahlin1
1Consolidated Nuclear Security, L.L.C., USDOE-NNSA Pantex Plant, PO Box 30020, Amarillo, Texas 79120. 2Current address: 8500 Kemper Road, Canyon, Texas 79015. *Corresponding author.
Praire Naturalist, Volume 54 (2022):N1–N3
Abstract
Cynomys ludovicianus Baird (Black-Tailed Prairie Dog) is considered to be a keystone species in the prairie, providing food and habitat for a diversity of wildlife. In October of 2020, we observed an active Apis mellifera Linnaeus (European Honey Bee) hive visible within the entrance of a burrow made by Black-Tailed Prairie Dogs in the treeless plains of the Texas Panhandle. This observation suggests that prairie dogs could provide habitat for this economically important pollinator and in landscapes otherwise devoid of cavities such as are commonly found in trees, buildings, and other structures.
Download Full-text pdf
Prairie Naturalist Notes
J.D. Ray and T. Mahlin
2022 54:N1–N3
N1
2021
Use of a Black-Tailed Prairie Dog Burrow
by Honey Bees in the Texas Panhandle
James D. Ray1,2,* and Todd Mahlin1
Abstract - Cynomys ludovicianus Baird (Black-Tailed Prairie Dog) is considered to be a keystone
species in the prairie, providing food and habitat for a diversity of wildlife. In October of 2020, we
observed an active Apis mellifera Linnaeus (European Honey Bee) hive visible within the entrance
of a burrow made by Black-Tailed Prairie Dogs in the treeless plains of the Texas Panhandle. This
observation suggests that prairie dogs could provide habitat for this economically important pollinator
and in landscapes otherwise devoid of cavities such as are commonly found in trees, buildings, and
other structures.
Cynomys ludovicianus Baird (Black-Tailed Prairie Dog) is considered to be a keystone
species in the prairie (Kotliar et al. 1999), providing food and habitat for bats, birds, small
mammals, reptiles, amphibians, and invertebrates (Adams 2021, Duchhardt et al. 2021, Mc-
Caffrey 2001, McCaffrey et al. 2009, Pruett et al. 2010, Ray et al. 2015). While mapping
the boundary of a colony of Black-Tailed Prairie Dogs at the US Department of Energy-
National Nuclear Security Administration’s (DOE-NNSA) Pantex Plant in Carson County,
Texas, on 20 October 2020 (09:30), we encountered a hive of Apis mellifera Linnaeus
(European Honey Bee) within a prairie dog burrow. The prairie dog colony was located
on a satellite property of the Pantex Plant, separated from the main property by ~8.8 km
NE, or 18.1 km NE of the intersection of Interstate Highway 40 and Farm to Market Road
2373. The bee hive was in a burrow on the south boundary of the colony (35°22'47.11"N,
101°29'30.02"W).
The burrow entrance was oriented to the south and we observed at least two fresh white
combs visible in the entrance. The bees were active, flying in and out of the burrow and
working on the comb’s surface. Although the outside layers of comb blocked our view of
how deep the hive extended, it is probable that the entirety of the hive was in the long, narrow
entrance tunnel, rather than any large internal chamber. We did not have the bees tested
for Africanized traits, because testing is no longer conducted in Texas, given the Africanized
genes are considered to occur statewide (M. Reed, Texas Apiary Inspection Service, College
Station, TX; 2020 pers. comm.).
We revisited the burrow on 8 February 2021 (13:30), and it was apparent that an animal,
most likely a Mephitis mephitis Gray (Striped Skunk) or Taxidea taxus Schreber (American
Badger), had dug out and depredated much of the comb (Fig. 1). It appeared that there were
no active bees remaining at that time and activity was not observed on several follow-up
visits in the spring.
Our observations of this hive are important for two reasons: 1) these observations provide
what is believed to be the first evidence that Black-Tailed Prairie Dog burrows can
possibly support hives of this economically-important pollinator, and 2) the observation
further illustrates the importance of Black-Tailed Prairie Dogs to biodiversity in the prairie.
1Consolidated Nuclear Security, L.L.C., USDOE-NNSA Pantex Plant, PO Box 30020, Amarillo,
Texas 79120. 2Current address: 8500 Kemper Road, Canyon, Texas 79015. *Corresponding author:
Jdraypuma@gmail.com.
Associate Editor: Drew Ricketts, Horticulture and Natural Resources, Kansas State University.
2022 PRAIRIE NATURALIST NOTES 54:N1–N3
Prairie Naturalist Notes
J.D. Ray and T. Mahlin
2022 54:N1–N3
N2
The European Honey Bee is important economically in the US (Patel et al. 2021), providing
$1.6–$5.7 billion in social gains each year through pollination services (Southwick
and Southwick 1992). Wherever honey bees are kept, feral colonies can become established
through swarming (Villa 2004), and established feral colonies can be sources for further
increases in local populations. Wild colonies of honey bees are documented to prefer large
enclosed cavities with, generally, small or narrow entrances that are at least 3–5 m above
ground surface (Avitabile et al. 1978; Seeley and Morse 1976, 1978). Honey bees with Africanized
genes tend to nest underground at a higher rate than those lacking Africanized genes
(Sanford 2006). Still, a review conducted by Saunders et al. (2021) of iNaturalist data found
that only 2.8% of 326 honey bee hives documented were in underground cavities. Hives can
occur in abandoned animal burrows (Saunders et al. 2021), but most underground hives are
located in fissures in rock, under rock overhangs, and cavities in cliff faces and clay banks
(Saunders et al. 2021, Wenner et al. 1992). Predation rates on hives in prairie dog burrows
and other animal burrows warrants further investigation to understand the contribution of
these cavities to local populations of honey bees.
Trees on the western Great Plains can be scarce and concentrated near water sources and
human settlements, potentially limiting opportunities for colonization of tree cavities by
honey bees. Thus, colonies of Black-Tailed Prairie Dogs may provide honey bees additional
habitat in areas that are otherwise void of suitable cavities.
Acknowledgements
Funding for the fieldwork that led to the finding of the beehive was provided by the USDOENNSA
in cooperation with Consolidated Nuclear Security, L.L.C. C. Boal, J. Booker, and S. Longing
provided helpful comments on this manuscript. Neither the US Government nor Consolidated
Nuclear Security, LLC, nor their employees, warrants or assumes any legal liability associated with
the information contained herein. This manuscript has been authored by CNS, under Contract No DEFigure
1. Honey comb in an enlarged entrance to a prairie dog burrow on the Pantex Plant, after predation
by a mammalian predator (8 February, 2020; James D. Ray).
Prairie Naturalist Notes
J.D. Ray and T. Mahlin
2022 54:N1–N3
N3
NA0001942 with the US Department of Energy. The US Government retains and the publisher, by
accepting the article for publication, acknowledges that the US Government retains a non-exclusive,
paid-up, irrevocable, world-wide license to publish or reproduce the published form of this manuscript,
or allow others to do so, for US Government purposes.
Literature Cited
Adams, R.A. 2021. Do black-tailed prairie dogs (Cynomys ludovicianus) colonies attract foraging
bats? Journal of Zoology. Journal of Zoology 315(2):156–163.
Avitabile A., D.P. Stafstrom, and K.J. Donovan. 1978. Natural nest sites of honey bee colonies in trees
in Connecticut, USA. Journal of Apicultural Research 17:222–226.
Duchardt, C.J., L.M. Porensky, and I.S. Pearse. 2021. Direct and indirect effects of a keystone engineer
on a shrubland-prairie food web. Ecology 102(1):1–13.
Kotliar, N.B., B.W. Baker, A.D. Whicker, and G. Plumb. 1999. A critical review of assumptions about
the prairie dog as a keystone species. Environmental Management 24(2):177–192.
McCaffrey, R.E. 2001. Biodiversity associated with active and extirpated black-tailed prairie dog
colonies. M.S. thesis, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX. 80 pp.
McCaffrey, R.E., M.C. Wallace, and J.D. Ray. 2009. Small mammals and ground-dwelling invertebrates
associated with active and controlled colonies of black-tailed prairie dogs (Cynomys
ludovicianus). Southwestern Naturalist 54(3):300–306.
Patel, V., N. Pauli, E. Biggs, L. Barbour, and B. Boruff. 2021. Why bees are critical for achieving
sustainable development. Ambio 50:49–59.
Pruett, A.L., C.W. Boal, M.C. Wallace, H.A. Whitlaw, and J.D. Ray. 2010. Small mammals associated
with colonies of black-tailed prairie dogs in the Southern High Plains. Southwestern Naturalist
55(1):50–56.
Ray, J.D., M.C. Wallace, and R. E. McCaffrey. 2015. Avian use of black-tailed prairie dog colonies in
shortgrass prairie. Great Plains Research 25(1):75–82.
Sanford, M.T. 2006. The Africanized honey bee in the Americas: A biological revolution with human
cultural implications. American Bee Journal 146(7):597–599.
Saunders M.E., E.K. Goodwin, K.C.B.S. Santos, C.A. Sonter, and R. Rader. 2021. Cavity occupancy
by wild honey bees: need for evidence of ecological impacts. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment
19(6):349–354.
Seeley T.D. and R.A. Morse. 1976. The nest of the honey bee (Apis mellifera L). Insect Sociaux
23:495–512.
Seeley T.D., and R.A. Morse. 1978. Nest site selection by the honey bee, Apis mellifera. Insect Sociaux
25:323–337.
Southwick, E.E. and L. Southwick, Jr. 1992. Estimating the economic value of honey bees (Hymenoptera:
Apidae) as agricultural pollinators in the United States. Journal of Economic Entomology
85(3):621–633.
Villa, J.D. 2004. Swarming behavior of honey bees (Hymenoptera: Apidae) in southeastern Louisiana.
Annals of the Entomological Society of America 97(1):111–116.
Wenner, A.M., J.E. Alcock, and D.E. Meade. 1992. Efficient hunting of feral colonies. Bee Science
2:64–70.