ii Journal of the North Atlantic Special Volume 3
ii
This project all began in 1982 when one of the
editors, J. Arneborg, was preparing for her first
fieldwork in Greenland and Henrik Tauber, then
head of the carbon-14 Dating Laboratory at the National
Museum in Copenhagen, had published his
ground-breaking article in Nature, where he used the
13C fractionation pattern to demonstrate the dramatic
change from Danish Mesolithic man’s dependence
on marine food sources to Neolithic man’s predominant
subsistence on terrestrial food (Tauber 1981).
Tauber wanted to continue his research on the
marine effects on carbon isotope ratios and radiocarbon
dating and the consequences for the study of
past dietary habits. When he learned that the Greenland
National Museum had initiated archaeological
excavations at the Norse magnate farm Anavik in
the Norse Western Settlement under the direction of
Hans Kapel and with Jette Arneborg as participant,
Tauber asked us to collect Norse skeletal material
and, for the assessment of marine radiocarbon
reservoir effects in the skeletal samples, he also
wanted terrestrial samples from the same graves for
comparison of the radiocarbon dates. We managed
to collect human skeletal samples and charcoal from
three graves, and the δ13C results were astonishing.
The burials were dated to the later period of the
Western Settlement, and according to the δ13C values,
the Norse had had a predominantly marine diet
very similar to the pre-1721 Inuit population (Tauber
1989). The 1982 Anavik results are published in this
volume for the first time (Arneborg et al. 2012).
It was tempting to look further into the diet
of the Norse Greenlanders, but the conventional
radiocarbon method required large amounts of
bone, and it would be almost impossible to get the
permission from Danish National Museum to take
samples from the Norse skeletal collections at the
Laboratory of Biological Anthropology at the University
of Copenhagen.
Things had changed when N. Lynnerup began
his PhD project in 1992 on the Norse human skeletal
material. Again, analysis of diet and precise dating
were necessary, but at this point in time, a new
method for radiocarbon dating, requiring a thousand
times less sample material, had become available in
Denmark. The AMS (accelerator mass spectrometry)
method had been implemented at Aarhus University
by upgrading the existing 5 megavolt tandem accelerator
through the joint efforts of the physicists
H.L. Nielsen, N. Rud, and J. Heinemeier (Arneborg
et al. 2002). Stable isotope analysis was available
through collaboration with Árný Sveinbjörnsdóttir
at Science Institute, University of Iceland. The first
collaborative efforts in the early 1990s thus resulted
in the first AMS-datings and 13C analyses of Norse
human skeletons (Arneborg et al. 1999, Lynnerup
1998). Again, some exciting results were obtained:
e.g., the Bishop found interred at Gardar was shown
to have a much more terrestrial diet than his flock—
in line with him not having been raised in Greenland
and then when living in Greenland probably consuming
a more elite diet of terrestrial animal meat.
Most interesting was a further corroboration of the
above first results from Anavik: the Norse seemed
to have changed their dietary habits, and indeed
their whole dietary economy, towards a much larger
marine component. Could this give us new insights
about the history, and demise, of the Norse settlements
in Greenland?
Further studies on a larger scale would be needed
to solve this. Thus, an application was made to
the Carlsberg Foundation resulting in a generous
three-year grant that became the basis of the study
presented here: a comprehensive dietary analysis
of the Norse, including the animals—terrestrial and
marine, tame and wild—that formed part of their diet
and similar analyses of the contemporary Thule Culture
Inuit and their game animals. With assistance
from the Danish Natural Science Research Council
and SILA (The Danish National Museum), our research
team was expanded with E. Nelson of Simon
Fraser University, Vancouver, BC, Canada and Jeppe
Møhl of the University of Copenhagen Zoological
Museum.
What we present here is one of the most comprehensive
studies to date of the food consumption
and dietary economy of a historical population based
on stable isotope analysis. The Norse Greenlanders
are in this respect particularly of interest because
their settlements in Greenland were constrained
Foreword
Jette Arneborg1,2,*, Jan Heinemeier3, and Niels Lynnerup4
Special Volume 3:ii–iii
Greenland Isotope Project: Diet in Norse Greenland AD 1000–AD 1450
Journal of the North Atlantic
1Danish Middle Ages and Renaissance, Research and Exhibitions, The National Museum of Denmark, Frederiksholms
Kanal 12, DK-1220 Copenhagen, Denmark. 2Institute of Geography, School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh,
Scotland UK. 3AMS 14C Dating Centre, Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, Ny Munkegade
120, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark. 4Laboratory of Biological Anthropology, Section of Forensic Pathology, University of
Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark. *Corresponding author - jette.arneborg@natmus.dk.
2012
2012 XXX iii
chronologically (ca. 500 years) and physically (the
pasture lands of Southwestern Greenland). Archaeological
efforts in Greenland have very likely uncovered
all the settlement areas, including churches and
cemeteries; thus, we can be reasonably assured that
while new finds of, e.g., farmsteads may appear in
future, the overall picture of the Norse settlements is
pretty much fixed. It is these constraints that allow
us to focus on the major and minor changes of their
dietary economy. An important key to this approach
is, of course, high-resolution dating and the development
of a highly detailed chronological framework
in the cemeteries, which allow us to record the
changes over time using the human skeletons.
This special volume is divided into 7 interdependent
chapters or articles. They can be read
separately, and although the individual papers have
various author combinations, the three of us have
had the stewardship of the final editing and collation
of the papers. The Carlsberg Foundation grant was
given 1998–2000. While admittedly some time has
passed since we first began this study, we do hope
that this volume, with single chapters detailing various
aspects of the study, alongside a comprehensive
presentation of the raw data, has been worth the
effort!
Literature Cited:
Arneborg, J. 1996. Burgunderhuer, baskere og døde
nordboer i Herjolfsnæs, Grønland. Nationalmuseets
Arbejdsmark 1996:75–83.
Arneborg, J., J. Heinemeier, N. Lynnerup, H.L. Nielsen,
N. Rud, and Á.E. Sveinbjörndóttir. 1999. Change of
diet of the Greenland Vikings determined from stable
carbon isotope analysis and 14C dating of their bones.
Radiocarbon 41(5):157–168.
Arneborg J, J. Heinemeier, N. Lynnerup, H.L. Nielsen,
N. Rud, and A.E. Sveinbjörnsdóttir 2002. C-14 dating
and the disappearance of Norsemen from Greenland.
Europhysics News 33(3)(May/June):77–80.
Arneborg, J., N. Lynnerup, J. Heinemeier, J. Møhl, N.
Rud, and Á.E. Sveinbjörndóttir 2012 [this volume].
Norse Greenland dietary economy ca. AD 980–ca.
AD 1450: Introduction. Journal of the North Atlantic
Special Volume 3:1–39.
Lynnerup, N. 1998. The Greenland Norse. A biological-
anthropological study. Meddelelser om Grønland –
Man & Society 24. The Commission for Scientific Research
in Greenland, Copenhagen, Denmark. 149 pp.
Tauber, H. 1981. C-13 evidence for dietary habits of prehistoric
man in Denmark. Nature 292:332–333.
Tauber, H. 1989. Age and diet of the mummified
Eskimos from Qilakitsoq. Pp. 137–138, In J.P. Hart
Hansen and H.C. Gulløv (Eds.). The Mummies from
Qilakitsoq: Eskimos in the 15th Century. Meddelelser
om Grønland, Man & Society 12, Copenhagen, Denmark.
199 pp.