2010 NORTHEASTERN NATURALIST 17(3):437–454
Soil Respiration and Ecosystem Carbon Stocks in New
England Forests with Varying Soil Drainage
Aletta A. Davis1,2, Jana E. Compton1,3,*, and Mark H. Stolt1
Abstract - Northern temperate forests play an important role in the global carbon (C)
cycle. Individual stands can differ in C content and storage, based on characteristics
such as vegetation type, site history, and soil properties. These site differences may
cause stands to vary in their response to extreme weather events such as droughts. We
examined ecosystem C pools, soil respiration, and litterfall in four hardwood stands
with widely varying soil drainage in Rhode Island. Total ecosystem C increased as
soils became more poorly drained, ranging from 181 Mg C ha-1 in the excessively
drained Entisol to 547 Mg C ha-1 in the very poorly drained Histosol. The proportion
of ecosystem C contained in the soil was much higher in the poorly drained
soils, and ranged from 57% in the excessively drained Entisol to 91% in the poorly
drained Histosol. While total ecosystem C stocks varied by a factor of three, rates
of litterfall and soil respiration were similar among sites. Soil carbon content was
highest in the very poorly drained site, and respiration was lowest from this site.
During the summer drought of 1999, all soils except the Histosol had lower respiration
rates than predicted from temperature alone. Rain events that ended the drought
produced a pulse of soil respiration in all mineral soils, stimulating soil C flux more
than expected from temperature alone. The effect of drought and rewetting on soil
respiration varied by site, suggesting that the response to climate variability will
depend upon soil drainage to some extent. Soil respiration rates were most variable
in dry conditions, and current and antecedent soil moisture conditions played an
important role during those times. In general, soil respiration was much more variable
over time than across sites, even among these sites with very different total soil
C content, indicating that climate—mainly temperature—is the main determinant of
soil CO2 release even across soils with widely varying drainage.
Introduction
Northern temperate forests are a net sink for atmospheric carbon dioxide
(CO2), largely as a consequence of forest regrowth on abandoned farmland,
fire suppression, and possible fertilization by increasing atmospheric CO2
and nitrogen (N) deposition (Goodale et al. 2002, Magnani et al. 2007, Pacala
et al. 2001). From 1900 to 2000, forest cover in Rhode Island increased
from 20% to 70% of the landscape (Hooker and Compton 2003). While
large-scale modeling indicates that regrowing forests are net carbon (C)
sinks when aggregated over large geographic areas, within these regions
1Department of Natural Resources Science, University of Rhode Island, Kingston,
RI. 2Current address - Department of Forestry and Environmental Sciences, North
Carolina State University, Campus Box 8002, Raleigh, NC 27695. 3Current address
- US Environmental Protection Agency, National Health and Environmental Effects
Research Laboratory, Western Ecology Division, 200 SW 35th Street, Corvallis, OR
97333. *Corresponding author - compton.jana@epa.gov.
438 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
variation exists in ecosystem types, soil drainage (Davidson and Lefebvre
1993), rates of N deposition (Ollinger et al. 1993), and current and historical
management land-use history (Foster et al. 1998). All of these factors can
influence ecosystem C storage.
Soil drainage is a potentially important site factor influencing ecosystem
C balances under a changing climate. Soil respiration and net ecosystem C
exchange are strongly related to temperature (Lloyd and Taylor 1994), but
soil moisture can influence this relationship (Davidson et al. 1998, Nikolova
et al. 2009, Xu and Qi 2001). Wetter sites may have lower soil respiration on
an annual basis, but during dry periods, poorly drained soils could serve as
substantial sources of available C to be respired and added to the atmospheric
pool (Savage and Davidson 2001). Soil moisture can vary dramatically
among forests spatially, and within a forest over seasonal and inter-annual
time scales.
Our objective was to determine how temporal and spatial variation in soil
water availability influences forest ecosystem C stocks and soil respiration
in southern New England. We examined sites presented as part of the soil
C inventory conducted by Davis et al. (2004). The current paper presents
ecosystem C pools including vegetation (above and belowground biomass
and soil C to 1 m depth), plus litterfall and soil respiration of four hardwood
stands covering the extremes of soil drainage from excessively drained to
very poorly drained. The occurrence of a severe drought during the summer
of 1999 also provided the opportunity to examine the differential response
of this range of soil drainage classes to prolonged drying. We hypothesized
that respiration would increase dramatically in the poorly drained soils during
drought, since they would dry out and decomposition would no longer
be limited by low-oxygen conditions (Scanlon and Moore 2000). We also
hypothesized that well-drained soils would have little change or even a
decrease in soil respiration during drought as a result of increased water
limitation of microbial activity.
Methods
Site description
This study was conducted in the Pawcatuck Watershed in Rhode Island.
We further examined a subset of sites where we previously measured soil
C (Davis et al. 2004). The climate is temperate, with a mean annual temperature
of 9.1 °C, mean monthly maximum of 21.1 °C, and mean monthly
minimum of -3.7 °C. Annual precipitation averages 1270 mm, distributed
relatively evenly throughout the year (data from Kingston NOAA weather
station site; Carl Sawyer, NOAA, Kingston, RI, pers. comm.). We chose
four soil types for study, which represent a range of drainage classes, parent
materials, and textures (Rector 1981): the loamy sand phase of the Windsor
series (Entisol) formed in glacial outwash (excessively drained; ED), the silt
loam phase of the Enfield series (Inceptisol) formed in loess-over-outwash
(well drained; WD), silt loam phase of the Raypol series (Inceptisol) formed
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 439
in loess-over-outwash (poorly drained; PD), and the Carlisle series (Histosol)
that forms in organic deposits (very poorly drained; VPD).
Forests ranged in age from 64–105 years and were dominated by hardwood
trees (Table 1). Mixed Quercus (oak) species and Acer rubrum L. (Red
Maple) dominated the ED and WD sites, with Red Maple increasing in dominance
in the PD site. The presence of a plow layer (Ap horizon) indicated
that all three mineral soil series were historically cultivated (ED Entisol,
WD Inceptisol, and PD Inceptisol). The VPD Carlisle site is classified as
a Red Maple swamp and was probably not cleared for agriculture. There is
evidence that swamps in this region remained as isolated woodlands within
an agricultural landscape (Foster et al. 1992). These swamps were not completely
undisturbed, and during the last century may have been selectively
harvested in winter months when the frozen peat made for easier timber
removal (F. Golet, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI, pers. comm.).
Soil sampling and analysis
Soil C for a range of sites was determined by Davis et al. (2004); the
sites examined in this paper are a subset of that larger sampling effort. We
build upon the Davis et al. (2004) soil work and determined above- and
belowground biomass, litterfall, and soil respiration for this subset of
sites. One map unit per soil series was chosen for estimating total ecosystem
C storage (Table 1). Both plot (20-m x 20-m) and random transect
(100-m length) sampling approaches were used in this study. Plot-scale
measurements provide detailed information on ecosystem components
and are a manageable scale at which to study ecosystem processes. To
better estimate the variability of the soil C pool across larger stands, random
transects were used to distribute the soil sampling locations across
the map unit. Soil morphology and classification within the plots were
representative of transects.
Two 100-m transects were identified within each map unit, and sampled
at 25-m intervals along each transect. Soil samples from the three soil series
developed in mineral soil (Windsor, Enfield, and Raypol) were collected
by horizon to a depth of 1 m using a 47-mm diameter split-core sampler
and slide hammer. A total of 10 cores were collected from each site. The
O horizon was collected intact from a 15-cm x 15-cm area and later separated
into Oi, Oe, and Oa materials. In the organic soil (Carlisle), fibric and
hemic horizons were collected using the 15- x 15-cm area, while sapric horizons
were collected by horizon using a Macauley peat sampler. Bulk density
calculations were corrected for >2-mm coarse fragment mass and volume.
Loss-on-ignition was determined for all soils by combustion at 550 °C for 5
hours (Nelson and Sommers 1996). Samples were analyzed for total C concentration
using an automated combustion NA1500 Carlo-Erba CN analyzer
(Carlo-Erba Instruments, Milan, Italy). The C concentration was multiplied
by the <2-mm soil mass for each horizon to obtain an areal estimate of total
soil C.
440 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
Plot-level biomass and litterfall
In order to estimate stand establishment age, the largest tree (based on
diameter at 1.4 m) within 10–15 m of each sampling point along the 100-m
transects was cored at the base, and we mounted the cores and counted tree
rings using a dissecting microscope. Stand age was estimated from the mean
age of the four oldest trees cored at each site (Table 1). Basal area at each
sampling point along the 100-m transect was estimated by prism.
Within each mapping unit, one 20-m x 20-m plot was established for
the detailed study of ecosystem C pools and fluxes. Plots were located in an
area considered to be representative of the mapping unit. Soil auger borings
were made within and around the edges of each plot to confirm that soil
morphology was representative of the entire unit; if a mapping unit was very
heterogeneous, a new mapping unit was selected. Basal area estimates from
transect sampling were compared to the basal area within each plot to identify
areas where the vegetation present within the plot was similar in basal
area to the transects (Table 1).
Table 1. Soil and vegetation characteristics by site. Stand age, transect basal area, and plant
composition are from the 100-m transect sampling. Plot basal area and trees per hectare are
from the 20-m x 20-m plots.
Site (by soil type)
Characteristic Windsor Enfield Raypol Carlisle
Soil order Entisol Inceptisol Inceptisol Histosol
Great group Psamment Dystrudept Endoaquept Medsaprist
Drainage class Excessively Well drained Poorly drained Very poorly
drained drained
Stand age (yr)A 64 81 105 105
Transect basal area 23.0 26.9 25.7 18.6
(m2 ha-1)
Plot basal area 20.5 28.2 32.4 18.9
(m2 ha-1)
Trees (ha-1)B 600 800 550 400
Composition
Overstory (O)C Q. r., Q. a., A. r., P. r., Q. r., A. r., Q. a. A. r., C. t.
Q. c., Q. v. Q. c., Q. a N. s.
Understory (U)D G. b., V. p. Lycopodium sp. S. r., T. r., V. d., C. a., S. f.
Lycopodium sp.
AStand age was determined by taking the mean age of the four oldest trees cored at each site.
BLive trees, >5 cm diameter at 1.4 m (DBH).
CQ. r. = Quercus rubra L. (Northern Red Oak), Q. a. = Q. alba L. (White Oak), Q. c. = Q. coccinea
Muenchh. (Scarlet Oak), Q. v. = Q. velutina Lam. (Black Oak), A. r. = Acer rubrum L.
(Red Maple), P. r. = Pinus rigida P. Mill (Pitch Pine), N. s. = Nyssa Sylvatica L. (Blackgum),
C. t. = Chamaecyparis thyoides (L.) B.S.P. (Atlantic White Cedar).
DG. b. = Gaylussacia bacata (Wangenh.) K. Koch. (Black Huckleberry), V. p. = Vaccinium pallidum
Aiton (Lowbush Blueberry), S. r. = Smilax rotundifolia L. (Roundleaf Greenbrier), T. r.
= Toxicodendron radicans (L.) Kuntze (Poison Ivy), V. d. = Viburnum dentatum L. (Southern
Arrowwood), C. a. = Clethra alnifolia L. (Sweet Pepperbush), and S. f. = Symplocarpus foetidus
(L.) Salisb. ex Nutt. (Skunk Cabbage).
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 441
Tree biomass was estimated using published allometric equations based
on diameter at 1.4 m (Tritton and Hornbeck 1982). Carbon storage in aboveand
belowground overstory biomass was calculated based on average C
concentrations in hardwoods and softwoods of the Northeast (0.521 and
0.498 g C g-1, respectively; Birdsey 1992). Regional estimates of the proportion
of root biomass to total aboveground biomass for hardwoods (0.1834)
and softwoods (0.2048) were used to estimate root biomass (Birdsey 1992).
Understory aboveground biomass was determined by destructively sampling
three 2-m x 2-m areas during September and early October 1999 before
vegetation began to senesce. Understory biomass was collected from three
randomly selected locations outside the 20-m x 20-m plots, no more than
10 m away from any edge of the larger study plots in order to minimize disturbance
of the respiration plots. Although we did not measure coarse woody
debris in the present study, Hooker and Compton (2003) found that this pool
contained <3% of total ecosystem C in Pinus strobus L. (White Pine) stands
on well-drained soils in Rhode Island.
Litterfall was measured within each plot at regular intervals for one full
year (June 1999–May 2000). Three plastic litter baskets (38 cm x 52.5 cm)
were located randomly in each plot to capture litterfall. All litter was collected
biweekly during the fall and monthly throughout the rest of the year.
The litter was dried at 105 °C to constant weight. Carbon in the understory
and litter were estimated assuming a C concentration of 0.50 g C g-1 (Houghton
1996).
Soil respiration
Point-in-time CO2 fluxes from the soil surface were measured from June
1999 to May 2000 with a Li-Cor 6262 infrared gas analyzer (Li-Cor, Lincoln,
NE) using the dynamic, closed-chamber method (Rolston 1986) as described
by Davidson et al. (1998). Beveled-edge 25-cm diameter PVC rings were
installed at approximately 2–3 cm into the forest floor to form a seal at the
soil surface with minimal impact on fine roots (Raich and Nadelhoffer 1989).
Rings were permanently placed at four randomly selected points within each
20-m x 20-m plot. Ambient CO2 was measured for 60 seconds by placing the
chamber on its side near the ring. After 60 seconds, the PVC chamber was fitted
snugly over the ring for 5 minutes. Carbon dioxide concentrations within
the chamber were recorded at 3-second intervals. Chamber concentrations
were plotted as a function of time, and a linear regression between the chamber
concentrations and time was fitted to a 60-second portion of the data to
calculate the rate of CO2 flux from the soil. The slope of the regression (CO2
rate) was converted to gaseous C losses on a g C m-2 d-1 basis. The airspace
volume was determined using five measurements of ring height. Biweekly
flux measurements began in June 1999 and ended in November 1999, except
for the Carlisle site, where measurements began in late July. Soil respiration
was measured monthly from May 1999 to May 2000.
Soil temperature beside each chamber was determined (10-cm soil
depth) from two instantaneous measurements each time soil respiration was
442 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
measured. In addition, hourly temperatures were measured throughout the
entire year for one random location within the plot, using a temperature logger
placed in the forest floor and the mineral soil at 10 cm (HOBO H8, Onset
Corporation, Woods Hole, MA). When temperature data were missing due to
equipment problems (<5% of the time), we used a linear regression between
that site’s temperature and the nearest site’s temperature for the 10 days
prior to and following the data gap to fill the gap. At each time we measured
respiration, we also collected randomly located soil samples (n = 3) for soil
moisture (using a 6-cm diameter steel sampler for organic soils and a 4.5-
cm diameter steel corer for the mineral soils). These samples were collected
away from the rings to avoid disturbance, but should represent the relative
soil moisture conditions during the period respiration was measured. Soil
moisture was determined by drying for 24 hours at 105 °C. Average bulk
density for these soil depths was determined from the transect data by series,
and then soil moisture (g H2O g-1 soil) was converted to volumetric water
content (cm3 cm-3). Daily precipitation data were obtained from a NOAA
weather station in Kingston, RI (C. Sawyer, University of Rhode Island,
Kingston, RI, pers. comm.).
Total annual CO2-C flux (Mg C ha-1 yr-1) from the soil surface was
estimated by developing CO2 vs. temperature regressions for each ring
in each of the four sites. This approach allowed us to calculate standard
errors and make comparisons across sites. Temperature data used in
these regressions were the average of the two probes inserted beside each
chamber when flux was measured. Daily average 10-cm soil temperature
for each sampling date was calculated from the hourly measurements recorded
by the data logger installed at each site. Soil temperatures (10 cm)
from the probes were within 1–2 °C of the hourly temperature measured
by the temperature datalogger at each site and strongly positively correlated.
Once the CO2-temperature regression equations for each ring were
calculated, daily average soil temperature for the site was used to extrapolate
annual CO2 emissions from each ring. Mean comparisons for the
point-in-time values were conducted using repeated measures analysis of
variance with SPSS (SPSS Science, Chicago, IL). Nonlinear regressions
were also conducted with SPSS.
Results
Carbon in vegetation, soils, and litterfall
Total aboveground biomass C increased with decreasing drainage in the
mineral soil types from 66 Mg C ha-1 in the ED Windsor site to 120 Mg C
ha-1 in the PD Raypol site (Table 2). The VPD Carlisle site had the lowest
biomass C of all sites. Understory biomass was a small proportion of total
ecosystem C (<1%; Table 2), and increased with drainage. The VPD Carlisle
site had the greatest understory C, and also highly variable accumulation of
C in the understory (CV = 125%), probably a result of the pronounced hummocky
or pit-and-mound nature of the soil surface.
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 443
Soil C was the largest pool of C stored within all four ecosystems. The
soil C pools (including O horizons) in the three mineral soils accounted for
57–62% of the total C in these forests, while in the VPD Carlisle site the
soil accounted for 91% of total ecosystem C (Table 2). Root biomass accounted
for only 6% of total ecosystem C in the mineral soils and 1% in the
organic soil. Soil C content was lowest in the ED Windsor (64 Mg C ha-1)
site. The VPD Carlisle site had over seven times more soil C than the ED
and WD sites, and more than two times more C than even the PD Raypol
site (190 Mg C ha-1).
Aboveground litterfall was similar across these sites (2.1–2.9 Mg C ha-1
yr-1), with lowest rates in the VPD site (Table 2). The ratio of litterfall to total
aboveground biomass varied from 2–5%. Litter inputs from mid-September
through the beginning of November accounted for the majority of total annual
aboveground litter inputs to the soil (68–85%, data not shown).
Soil respiration
There was substantial seasonal variation in soil respiration, with the
highest rates of respiration occurring from April to November (Fig. 1).
Soil respiration increased by a factor of 2–4 from June through August.
The highest point-in-time respiration was measured at the end of July in
the Histosol and in mid-August after rains in the Entisol and Inceptisols
(Fig. 1). Differences across sites were much more pronounced during these
peak times of soil respiration. Little variability among sites was observed
during the winter. Total annual soil respiration in these sites, based on the
average of the annual sum of daily individual ring estimates, ranged from
5.95–9.54 Mg C ha-1 yr-1, with the lowest fluxes occurring from the VPD
organic soil (Table 2).
Table 2. Carbon pools, distribution, and fluxes. Values are means, ± standard errors.
Soil type and drainage class
Windsor ED Enfield WD Raypol PD Carlisle VPD
Carbon pools (Mg C ha-1)
Plant
Overstory aboveground 65.0 94.5 118.5 37.8
Understory aboveground 1.0 ± 0.3 0.3 ± 0.1 1.7 ± 0.1 4.8 ± 3.5
Roots 11.6 18.1 21.7 7.2
Soil
Oi plus Oe horizon 40.3 ± 4.3 40.7 ± 4.3 37.7 ± 5.7 16.1 ± 6.1
Oa plus 0–100 cm depth 63.5 ± 3.3 128 ± 14.1 190 ± 13.2 486 ± 45.4
Total ecosystem C content 181 281 370 552
Carbon distribution (% of total)
Plant biomass (total) 43% 40% 38% 8%
Forest floor (Oi + Oe horizon) 22% 14% 10% 3%
Total soil (O horizon + 0–100 cm soil) 57% 60% 62% 92%
Carbon fluxes (Mg C ha-1 yr-1)
Aboveground litterfall 2.78 ± 0.30 2.87 ± 0.08 2.32 ± 2.20 2.12 ± 0.37
Soil respiration 9.08 ± 1.12 7.13 ± 0.73 9.54 ± 1.17 5.95 ± 0.92
444 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
We found that soil type had a marginally significant influence on soil
respiration (P = 0.088; Table 3). Sampling date and the interaction between
sampling date and soil type were highly significant factors influencing soil
respiration (P < 0.001), suggesting that moisture and temperature changes
over time were important and affected the sites in different ways. The ED
Windsor soil had slightly higher CO2 fluxes than the other soils throughout
the growing season, except for the early growing season and the peak of the
drought in late July, when the PD Raypol soil had the highest rates of soil
respiration. The highest total fluxes were observed in the PD Raypol site.
This finding could be most likely due to higher fluxes in the early growing
season and high rates during the dry, warm period when this site still had
abundant soil moisture (Fig. 2). The lowest respiration rates were observed
in the VPD Carlisle soil (Table 2).
Possible indications of drought effects can be observed by plotting measured
CO2 fluxes from these soils against predicted values based on daily
average soil temperature (Figs. 2, 3). Several time-periods stand out and may
indicate drought effects. Substantial drought occurred during June and July
1999 (Fig. 4). At the end of July 1999, soil respiration was much lower than
Figure 1. Soil respiration measured from the four study sites from May 1999 until
May 2000. Bars represent standard error (n = 4 rings per site).
Table 3. Repeated measures ANOVA effects on soil respiration.
Source DF MSE F P value
Soil 3 16.611 2.702 0.088
Ring (soil) 12 7.419 5.745 <0.001
Date 23 32.091 24,849.000 <0.001
Date*Soil 32 2.715 2.102 0.001
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 445
fluxes predicted solely from soil temperature in the Windsor, Enfield, and
Raypol soils (Fig. 2). Until this time, moisture does not appear to limit soil
respiration in these soils. In the second week of August it rained frequently,
and soil respiration measured just after this period was much higher than
predicted in the ED Windsor soil (Fig. 2) and indicate that CO2 fluxes were
moisture-limited in this soil near the end of summer.
While total ecosystem C differed by a factor of three (181 vs. 552 Mg
C ha-1) among these forests, soil respiration varied only by a factor of 1.5
(range = 6.0–9.1 Mg C ha-1 yr-1) and litterfall was uniform across sites
(range = 2.1–2.9 Mg C ha-1 yr-1). The similarity in soil respiration across
sites may have been the result of a severe drought during the summer of
1999. Low soil moisture appears to have negatively affected soil respiration
Figure 2. Soil respiration (predicted and measured), temperature, soil moisture
(0–10 cm mineral soil), and precipitation for the four sites. Predicted respiration was
determined using the site-specific exponential relationship shown in Figure 3. Precipitation
data were obtained from the NOAA weather station in Kingston, RI.
446 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
in the ED and WD soils for at least a portion of the drought. Soil respiration
declined significantly with increasing soil moisture for all sites (Table 4).
We conducted linear regressions using both soil moisture and temperature,
but only temperature was a significant predictor in these relationships. The
relationship between temperature and moisture is complex and generally
inverse over the course of the year (Table 4). Soil moisture is often highest
during the coldest periods, but can covary with temperature during certain
periods. Here, we examined temperature-moisture interactions by plotting
the residuals of the regression between respiration and temperature against
soil moisture (Fig. 5). Using this approach, we observe greater deviation
from the relationship at low soil moisture. This result suggests that soil
Figure 3. Relationship between soil temperature (10 cm) and CO2 efflux. Equations
shown are derived from the average of the relationships used for the calculation of
annual fluxes.
Table 4. Linear regressions of the influence of volumetric water content on CO2 fluxes. ns = not
significant (P > 0.05). ED = extremely well drained, WD = well drained, PD = poorly drained,
and VPD = very poorly drained.
Soil Depth Slope Intercept r2 P value
Windsor (ED) Forest floor -24.90 6.43 0.35 0.013
0–10 cm -21.19 6.32 0.18 ns
Enfield (WD) Forest floor -6.53 3.96 0.40 0.007
0–10 cm -9.28 4.83 0.43 0.004
Raypol (PD) Forest floor -5.31 4.82 0.27 0.038
0–10 cm -6.37 5.51 0.34 0.017
Carlisle (VPD) Forest floor -23.49 8.72 0.41 ns
0–10 cm -11.87 7.14 0.21 ns
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 447
temperature effects are less predictable during drought periods, and that
moisture availability influences respiration during those periods.
Discussion
Ecosystem C totals and distribution
Our study only examines one site per drainage class, thus making it difficult to draw inferences about the specific drivers of differences between
Figure 4. Daily precipitation and departure from a 30-year average from June 1999
through May 2000. Data obtained from the NOAA weather station in Kingston, RI.
Asterisks indicate periods of moderate or greater drought according to the Palmer
Drought Severity Index (National Climatic Data Center 1999–2000).
448 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
sites. We report these data and place them in the context of other studies
to assist in the interpretation. Plant biomass varied among sites, with the
maximum biomass occurring in the intermediate drainage classes. Our
Figure 5. Soil moisture vs. the residuals of soil respiration from the soil temperature
model for each site (nonlinear regression equations shown in Table 5).
Table 5. Regression equations (CO2 vs. 10-cm soil temperature) for individual rings of the
four sites.
Soil Ring Equation r2
Windsor 1 y = 0.2040e0.1589x 0.84
2 y = 0.2744e0.1726x 0.86
3 y = 0.3378e0.1611x 0.85
4 y = 0.3698e0.1348x 0.72
Enfield 1 y = 0.3538e0.1119x 0.83
2 y = 0.337e0.1438x 0.86
3 y = 0.4720e0.1056x 0.81
4 y = 0.5902e0.1084x 0.80
Raypol 1 y = 0.1607e0.1929x 0.83
2 y = 0.3117e0.1585x 0.78
3 y = 0.6417e0.1280x 0.86
4 y = 0.5137e0.1034x 0.66
Carlisle 1 y = 0.1203e0.2030x 0.88
2 y = 0.1930e0.1407x 0.85
3 y = 0.1704e0.1895x 0.82
4 y = 0.1202e0.1767x 0.82
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 449
estimates for overstory aboveground biomass C (38 to 118.5 Mg C ha-1) are
similar to those found in other studies. Botkin et al. (1993) estimated that
the aboveground biomass in deciduous forests of New England contains
40.2 Mg C ha-1 (89.4 Mg biomass ha-1 times 45% C from their study), which
is lower than our mineral soil sites but similar to the VPD site. Trettin et al.
(1999) found a similar range in biomass C (82.2–117.6 Mg C ha-1) for oak-,
hickory-, and maple-dominated forests in Tennessee. The site with VPD
Carlisle soil contained much less aboveground biomass C than the sites with
mineral soils (Table 2), even though the Carlisle stand was older. Soil moisture
status may limit C storage in aboveground biomass by limiting growth
at the extremes of drainage classification (ED and VPD soils).
Soil C stocks varied nearly five-fold with drainage class, reinforcing the
idea that soil drainage is a very important variable for incorporation into spatial
assessments of soil C (Tan et al. 2004). Soil C content was lowest in the
ED Windsor (104 Mg C ha-1) site. The VPD Carlisle site held 502 Mg soil C
ha-1, which is over seven times greater soil C than the ED site, and more than
twice greater than even the PD Raypol site. The VPD Carlisle site is a peat
soil, with bulk density of less than 0.2 g cm-3 and C concentrations were approximately
50% throughout the profile to 100 cm (Davis et al. 2004). Peat soils
have very high C content because anoxic conditions lead to very slow decomposition
and preservation of organic matter. Rapalee et al. (1998) found
that the largest C stocks occurred in poorly drained sites across the boreal
regions. The distribution of C throughout the three well-drained forests was
slightly different than the average US forest described by Birdsey (1992),
who estimated that above- and belowground vegetation accounted for ≈32%
of total ecosystem C storage. In our study, above- and belowground vegetation
on the three mineral soil sites accounted for a slightly higher proportion
of ecosystem C (38–42%), while vegetation in the Carlisle site accounted for
only 8% of total ecosystem C storage (Table 2).
Estimates of regional C storage often are based on broad categories of
ecosystem or soil types. This approach does not take into account the complexity
of these systems and the various factors that contribute to gains and
losses in C. Approximately 5-fold differences in soil C and 3-fold differences
in ecosystem C content were found among our study forests between
the excessively drained and very poorly drained sites. The most apparent
effect of soil type on ecosystem C storage was seen in the soil C pool, which
was greater in the VPD and PD soils. The differences in soil C pools were
not strongly related to present-day biomass, respiration, or litter inputs, but
are most likely a consequence of two potentially interacting factors: poor
organic matter quality, and the effects of poor soil drainage reducing turnover
and decomposition of organic matter. Our study cannot separate these
factors. However, we can gain some information on the importance of soil
moisture by comparing the short-term responses of soil respiration to changing
soil moisture status during wet and dry periods by drainage class.
450 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
Comparison of respiration and litterfall fluxes across sites
Our estimates of annual respiration rates (5.95–9.08 Mg C ha-1 yr-1) are
similar to other rates observed in hardwood forests of New England. Davidson
et al. (1998) reported an annual respiration rate of 7.2 Mg C ha-1 yr-1
for drought-affected forest soils at Harvard Forest, MA. In a five-year study
at Harvard Forest using eddy covariance techniques, Goulden et al. (1996)
found a range in soil CO2 effluxes from 8.1–11.4 Mg C ha –1 yr-1. Similar
soil respiration rates have been reported for oak forests and cedar swamps
in Minnesota (7.9 and 7.4 Mg C ha-1 yr-1, respectively [Reiners 1968], and
boreal aspen forests, 8.9 Mg C ha-1 yr-1 [Russell and Voroney 1998]).
Despite differences in aboveground biomass across the sites we studied,
litterfall inputs were similar across these sites. Litterfall for these sites
(2.12–2.78 Mg C ha -1 yr-1) were just below the range of 2.9–5.3 Mg C ha -1
yr-1 for hardwood forests reported by Scott and Binkley (1997). Similar litterfall
C fluxes (2.3–2.6 Mg C ha-1 yr-1) have been reported for hardwood
forests in the Appalachians (Garten et al. 1999), while lower litterfall (1.5
Mg C ha-1 yr-1) was reported for a well-drained site in central Massachusetts
(Gaudinski et al. 2000).
While soil and ecosystem carbon differed across sites by a factor of 5,
soil respiration varied only approximately 2-fold. We found a marginally
significant difference between sites in respiration (P = 0.088), and the very
poorly drained site had the lowest rates. Davidson et al. (1998) also found
that variability in soil respiration across the landscape was related to soil
drainage class, with better drained soils having higher rates. However, we
found that among mineral soils, the highest rates were observed in the poorly
drained site. This site tended to have consistently the highest rates during
the early growing season and high rates during the warmest periods. Differences
in respiration between sites were relatively small, indicating that even
with substantial differences in soil C stocks, respiration is largely driven by
temporal variations in temperature and moisture conditions.
Soil respiration: Interactions between soil temperature and moisture
Soil temperature was the main factor influencing soil respiration, as found
by others (Kicklighter et al. 1994), but soil moisture also influenced soil respiration
in our study (Fig. 2, Table 4). Low soil moisture can constrain soil CO2
efflux (Davidson et al. 1998, Linn and Doran 1984, Xu and Qi 2001). Volumetric
water content accounted for 18–43% of the variation in CO2 in the soils we
studied (Table 4), compared to 72–88% for soil temperature (Table 5). We did
not combine respiration and temperature into one model, since the relationship
is complex and may require information about the matric potential in upland
soils (Savage and Davidson 2001), which was not available for the study
sites. By plotting the residuals of the regression between respiration and temperature
against soil moisture (Fig. 5), we observed greater deviation from the
relationship at low soil moisture. This result indicates that during dry periods,
the relationship between soil temperature and respiration is weaker, possibly
due to the influence of moisture limitations during dry periods and release of
this limitation after rain events.
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 451
In the summer of 1999, New England suffered a moderate to severe
drought as reflected by the Palmer Drought Severity Index (http://www.
cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/index.html; Fig. 4). Monthly precipitation was far lower
than the 30-year average for April, June, and July 1999 (Fig. 4). Drought
periods can have substantial effects on soil moisture and in turn respiration.
Davidson et al. (1998) reported a significant effect of a 1995 drought on
soil respiration at volumetric water contents less than 12%. The ED Windsor
and WD Enfield sites had volumetric water contents of 12% or less on a
few sampling dates (Fig. 2). The ED Windsor site had low volumetric water
contents beginning in June and continuing through the middle of September.
The Enfield site experienced low water contents during the last two weeks of
June. In the ED and WD soils, soil respiration was lower than predicted from
temperature alone during periods of low volumetric water contents, which
suggests that soil respiration in the drier soils may have been moisturelimited
throughout the drought. During the periods when soil moisture was
the lowest (during the end of the 1999 summer drought), the VPD soil had
the highest soil respiration rates.
Our data suggest that there are key periods during which the soil respiration
is strongly regulated by soil moisture. Rainfall events at the end of
the drought period stimulated soil moisture flux more than predicted from
temperature alone. At the end of October, after an extended period of little
rainfall (Fig. 2), soil moisture increased and actual CO2 fluxes in the ED
Windsor and PD Raypol sites were also higher than predicted (Fig. 2). In
addition, at the beginning of the growing season in May 2000, actual CO2
fluxes were higher than predicted from temperature alone in the Windsor
and Enfield series (Fig. 2). Increased fluxes immediately following rainfall
events may be the response of roots or microbes to increased soil moisture in
the surface horizons of the soil (Borken et al. 2003, 2006; Law et al. 2001).
Our study, while limited because of a lack of replication, shows that ecosystem
carbon content can vary dramatically across sites, with poorly drained
soils having very high carbon contents. Climate variation, however, seems
to be the strongest regulator of the release of soil carbon from these mature
forests. Soil temperature was the main driver of soil respiration, with soil
moisture being a secondary factor, which was negatively related to respiration
during most of the year. Soil respiration rates were most variable during
droughts, and current and antecedent soil moisture conditions played an important
role during those times. Future efforts to understand the exchange of C
between soils and the atmosphere should continue to examine the importance
of climate variability and soil moisture on the net storage of carbon.
Acknowledgments
We thank José Amador and Keith Killingbeck for advice in the design and interpretation
of this study. Fred Pollnac assisted with the soil-respiration measurements.
This research was supported by the Rhode Island Agricultural Experiment Station.
452 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
Literature Cited
Birdsey, R.A. 1992. Carbon storage and accumulation in United States forest ecosystems.
USDA Forest Service, Washington, DC. General Technical Report 59.
Borken, W., E.A. Davidson, K. Savage, J. Gaudinski, and S.E. Trumbore. 2003.
Drying and wetting effects on carbon dioxide release from organic horizons. Soil
Science Society of America Journal 67:1888–1896.
Borken, W., E.A. Davidson, K. Savage, E.T. Sundquist, and P. Steudler. 2006. Effect
of summer throughfall exclusion, summer drought, and winter snow cover
on methane fluxes in a temperate forest soil. Soil Biology and Biochemistry
38:1388–1395.
Botkin, D. B., L.G. Simpson, and R.A. Nisbet. 1993. Biomass and carbon storage of
the North American deciduous forest. Biogeochemistry 20:1–17.
Davidson E.A., and P.A. Lefebvre. 1993. Estimating regional carbon stocks and spatially
covarying edaphic factors using soil maps at three scales. Biogeochemistry
22:107–131.
Davidson, E.A., E. Belk, and R.D. Boone. 1998. Soil water content and temperature
as independent or confounded factors controlling soil respiration in a temperate
mixed hardwood forest. Global Change Biology 4:217–227.
Davis, A.A., M.H. Stolt, and J. E. Compton. 2004. Spatial distribution of soil carbon
in southern New England hardwood forest landscapes. Soil Science Society of
America Journal 68:895–903.
Foster, D.R., T. Zebryk, P. Schoonmaker, and A. Lezberg. 1992. Post-settlement
history of human land-use and vegetation dynamics of a Tsuga canadensis (Hemlock)
woodlot in central New England. Journal of Ecology 80:773–786.
Foster D.R., G. Motzkin, and B. Slater. 1998. Land-use history as long-term broadscale
disturbance: Regional forest dynamics in central New England. Ecosystems
1:96–119.
Garten, C.T., Jr., W.M. Post III, P.J. Hanson, and L.W. Cooper. 1999. Forest soil
carbon inventories and dynamics along an elevation gradient in the southern Appalachian
Mountains. Biogeochemistry 45:115–145.
Gaudinski, J.B., S.E. Trumbore, E.A. Davidson, and S. Zheng. 2000. Soil carbon cycling
in a temperate forest soil: Radiocarbon-based estimates of residence times,
sequestration rates, and partitioning of fluxes. Biogeochemistry 51:33–69.
Goodale, C.L., M.J. Apps, R.A. Birdsey, C.B. Field, L.S. Heath, R.A. Houghton, J.C.
Jenkins, G. H. Kohlmaier, W. Kurz, S. Liu, G.-J. Nabuurs, S. Nilsson, and A.Z.
Shvidenko. 2002. Forest carbon sinks in the northern hemisphere. Ecological
Applications 12:891–899.
Goulden, M.L., J.W. Munger, S. Fan, B.C. Daube, and S.C. Wofsy. 1996. Exchange
of carbon dioxide by a deciduous forest: Response to interannual climate variability.
Science 271:1576–1578.
Hooker T.D., and J.E. Compton. 2003. Forest ecosystem C and N accumulation
during the first century after agricultural abandonment. Ecological Applications
13:299–313.
Houghton, R.A. 1996. Converting terrestrial ecosystems from sources to sinks of
carbon. Ambio 25:267–272.
Kicklighter, D.W., J.M. Melillo, W.T. Peterjohn, E.B. Rastetter, A.D. McGuire, and
P.A. Steudler. 1994. Aspects of spatial and temporal aggregation in estimating
regional carbon dioxide fluxes from temperate forest soils. Journal of Geophysical
Research 99:1303–1315.
2010 A.A. Davis, J.E. Compton, and M.H. Stolt 453
Law, B.E., A.H. Goldstein, P.M. Anthoni, J.A. Panek, M.H. Unsworth, M.R. Bauer,
J.M. Fracheboud, and N. Hultman. 2001. CO2 and water vapor exchange by
young and old Ponderosa Pine ecosystems during a dry summer. Tree Physiology
21:299–308.
Linn, D.M., and J.W. Doran. 1984. Effect of water-filled pore space on carbon dioxide
and nitrous oxide production in tilled and non-tilled soils. Soil Science
Society of America Journal 48:1267–1271.
Lloyd, J., and Taylor J.A., 1994. On the temperature dependence of soil respiration.
Functional Ecology 8:315–323.
Magnani, F., M. Mencuccini, M. Borghetti, P. Berbigier, F. Berninger, S. Delzon, A.
Grelle, P. Hari, P. G. Jarvis, P. Kolari, A. S. Kowalski, H. Lankreijer, B. E. Law,
A. Lindroth, D. Loustau, G. Manca, J. B. Moncrieff, M. Rayment, V. Tedeschi, R.
Valentini, and J. Grace. 2007. The human footprint in the carbon cycle of temperate
and boreal forests. Nature 447:849–851.
National Climatic Data Center. 1999–2000. Palmer drought severity indices. National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Rhode Island historical data
obtained in December 2009. Available online at http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/oa/
climate/research/drought/palmer-maps/. Accessed 30 December 2009.
Nelson, D.W., and L.E. Sommers. 1996. Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic
matter. Pp. 961–1010, In D.L. Sparks, A.L. Page, P.A. Helmke, R.H. Loeppert,
P.N. Soltanpour, M.A. Tabatabai, C.T. Johnston, and M.E. Sumner (Eds.). Methods
of Soil Analysis. Part 3: Chemical Methods. Soil Science Society of America,
Madison, WI.
Nikolova, P., S. Raspe, C. Andersen, R. Mainiero, H. Blaschke, R. Matyssek, and
K.-H. Häberle. 2009. Effects of the extreme drought in 2003 on soil respiration
in a mixed forest. European Journal of Forest Research 128:87–98.
Ollinger, S.V., J.D. Aber, G.M. Lovett, S.E. Milham, R.G. Lathrop, and G.M. Ellis.
1993. A spatial model of atmospheric deposition for the northeastern United
States. Ecological Applications 3:459–472.
Pacala, S.W., G.C. Hurtt, D. Baker, P. Peylin, R.A. Houghton, R.A. Birdsey, L. Heath,
E.T. Sundquist, R.F. Stallard, P. Ciais, P. Moorcroft, J.P. Caspersen, E. Shevliakova,
B. Moore, G. Kohlmaier, E. Holland, M. Gloor, M.E. Harmon, S.-M. Fan,
J.L. Sarmiento, C.L. Goodale, D. Schimel, and C.B. Field. 2001. Consistent landand
atmosphere-based US carbon sink estimates. Science 292:2316–2320.
Raich, J.W., and K.J. Nadelhoffer. 1989. Belowground carbon allocation in forest
ecosystems: Global trends. Ecology 70:1346–1354.
Rapalee, G., S.E. Trumbore, E.A. Davidson, J.W. Harden, and H. Veldhuis. 1998.
Soil carbon stocks and their rates of accumulation and loss in a boreal forest
landscape. Global Biogeochemical Cycles 12:687–701.
Rector, D.D. 1981. Soil survey of Rhode Island. United State Department of Agriculture,
Soil Conservation Service, Washington, DC.
Reiners, W.A. 1968. Carbon dioxide evolution from the floor of three Minnesota
forests. Ecology 49:471–483.
Rolston, D.E. 1986. Gas flux. Pp. 1103–1120, In A. Klute (Ed.). Methods of Soil
Analysis. Part 1. 2nd Edition. Agronomy Monograph 9. American Society of
Agronomy and Soil Science Society of America, Madison, WI.
Russel, C.A., and R.P. Voroney. 1998. Carbon dioxide efflux from the floor of a boreal
aspen forest. 1. Relationship to environmental variables and estimates of C
respired. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 78:301–310.
454 Northeastern Naturalist Vol. 17, No. 3
Savage, K.E., and E.A. Davidson. 2001. Interannual variation of soil respiration in
two New England forests. Global Biogeochemical Cycles 15:337–351.
Scanlon, D., and T. Moore. 2000. Carbon dioxide production from peatland soil
profiles: The influence of temperature, oxic/anoxic conditions, and substrate. Soil
Science 165:153–160.
Scott, N.A., and D. Binkley. 1997. Foliage litter quality and annual net N mineralization:
Comparison across North American forest sites. Oecologia 111:151– 159.
Tan, Z.X., R. Lal, N.E. Smeck, and F.G. Calhoun. 2004. Relationships between surface
soil organic carbon pool and site variables. Geoderma 121:187–195.
Trettin, C.C., D.W. Johnson, and D.E. Todd, Jr. 1999. Forest nutrient and carbon
pools at Walker Branch watershed: Changes during a 21-year period. Soil Science
Society of America Journal 63:1436–1448.
Tritton, L.M., and W.J. Hornbeck. 1982. Biomass equations for major tree species
of the Northeast. USDA Forest Service. General Technical Report NE-69. Northeastern
Forest Experiment Station, Radnor, PA.
Xu, M., and Y. Qi. 2001. Soil-surface CO2 efflux and its spatial and temporal variations
in a young Ponderosa Pine plantation in northern California. Global Change
Biology 7:667–677.