A Re-description of Cambarincola bobbi Holt, 1988, a Description of a New Species of Pterodrilus, and Observations of Sympatric Species of Crayfish Worms (Annelida: Clitellata: Branchiobdellida) from the Cumberland River Watershed in Tennessee
Bronwyn W. Williams and Stuart R. Gelder
Southeastern Naturalist, Volume 10, Issue 2 (2011): 199–210
Full-text pdf (Accessible only to subscribers.To subscribe click here.)
Site by Bennett Web & Design Co.
2011 SOUTHEASTERN NATURALIST 10(2):199–210
A Re-description of Cambarincola bobbi Holt, 1988,
a Description of a New Species of Pterodrilus, and
Observations of Sympatric Species of Crayfish Worms
(Annelida: Clitellata: Branchiobdellida) from the
Cumberland River Watershed in Tennessee
Bronwyn W. Williams1,* and Stuart R. Gelder2
Abstract - A re-description of Cambarincola bobbi Holt, 1988 is provided based on
observations made during recent collections in the Cumberland River Watershed in Tennessee.
The branchiobdellidan Pterodrilus robinae, a new species, is described, along
with a refinement for identification of five additional Pterodrilus species. Diversity, sympatry,
and range extensions of branchiobdellidans from three areas of the Cumberland
River Watershed are reported.
Branchiobdellidans, or crayfish worms, are freshwater ectosymbionts living
primarily on astacoidean crayfish. Two or more species are frequently
found on a single host, which is a characteristic reported in each of the three
disjunct regions of the taxon’s Holarctic distribution (Gelder 1999). The largest
diversity of branchiobdellidan taxa in the world is found in the mid-eastern
region of the USA, which supports 11 of the 21 nominal genera (Gelder et al.
2002). Therefore, it is not surprising that the record of eight species representing
five genera of branchiobdellidans on a single crayfish was found in
Tennessee (Brinkhurst and Gelder 2001). In spite of this local diversity, many
species have been recorded only from limited areas (Holt 1969, 1973; Holt
and Opell 1993), which may be more a reflection of the collection sites sampled,
rather than true distribution.
Branchiobdellidans were identified from crayfish collected from three counties
(Davidson, Overton, and Wilson) in central Tennessee as part of larger survey
in the State. The focus of this paper is a re-description of an existing species and
the description of a new species along with observations of additional sympatric
branchiobdellidans found at each collection site.
Materials and Methods
Crayfish were collected by hand and dip nets from three areas of the Cumberland
River Watershed in Tennessee during late April and mid-May 2010. Nine
specimens of Orconectes durelli Bouchard & Bouchard were obtained from a
1Department of Biological Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada T6G
2E9. 2Department of Science and Math, University of Maine at Presque Isle, 181 Main
Street, Presque Isle, ME 04769. *Corresponding author - email@example.com.
200 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
single site in Sevenmile Creek of the Mill Creek drainage, southeast of Nashville,
TN (N36.09118, W086.71908). One specimen of Cambarus tenebrosus Hay
was collected from a small tributary of Cedar Creek in Lebanon (N36.18833,
W86.37845). Four sites were sampled in Overton County, from which between
one and six crayfish of each species were taken, including specimens of Orconectes
placidus (Hagen) from Morgan Creek (N36.46165, W085.41045) and
Mill Creek (N36.47256, W85.42017) in Standing Stone State Park, Cambarus
tenebrosus from Mill Creek in the Standing Stone State Forest (N36.46253,
W085.37810), and Cambarus graysoni Faxon, C. tenebrosus, and O. placidus
from Flat Creek (N36.36089, W85.43347). Live branchiobdellidans were removed
from the host, prepared as wet mounts, and examined under a compound
microscope using bright-field illumination (Govedich et al. 2010). Branchiobdellidans
were preserved by placing them directly in 100% ethanol, and selected
specimens were cleared with methyl salicylate, infiltrated with Canada balsam,
and mounted on slides. Subsequent microscopical examination was carried out
under differential interference contrast illumination using a Nikon microscope.
Line drawings were produced with the aid of a drawing tube. Mounted specimens
of Cambarincola bobbi Holt were loaned to one author (S.R. Gelder) from the
National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington DC
(USNM catalog numbers are given in text below) for comparison with the newly
Results and Discussion
Although the majority of branchiobdellidan species were identified through
live preparations shortly after collection, a few groups remained problematic and
warranted detailed examination following permanent mounting. The morphology
of specimens in the latter groups appeared to differ sufficiently from, or display
characters absent in, the closest published descriptions. Subsequent examinations
of permanently mounted specimens resulted in species identifications, but
the problems encountered elicited a need to emend the species description of
C. bobbi as well as describe a new species of Pterodrilus. In view of the latter,
we present a revised diagrammatic key and comments on selected members of
the genus Pterodrilus. Both C. bobbi and the new Pterodrilus species were found
to live in sympatry with additional species, which are reported below.
Re-description of Cambarincola bobbi Holt, 1988 (Fig. 1A—G)
Brief description. Total length about 2.0 mm, head tubular, width about equal
segment 1, body slim terete, dorsal ridges absent; dorsal projections absent,
supernumerary muscles absent; lateral paired lobes segments 8 and 9 absent;
dorsal lip four lobes, lateral lobes two pairs, ventral lip median emargination;
oral papillae present; jaws similar size, shape triangular, teeth median larger,
laterals small, dental formula 5/5; pharyngeal sulcus one pair; glandular atrium
thick tubular, curved, length 0.7x segment diameter, deferent lobes absent; prostate
gland tubular slim, ends mid-glandular atrium, differentiated, ental bulb
present; muscular atrium tubular, length 0.3x segment diameter; bursa elongate
2011 B.W. Williams and S.R. Gelder 201
pyriform, length 0.4x segment diameter, penial sheath ental 0.4 of bursa, penis
ovoid, protrusible; spermatheca club-shaped, length 1.0x segment diameter, duct
shape tubular thick, length 0.5x organ, bulb shape ovoid, length 0.5x organ, ental
Variations. The only variation reported by Holt (1988) was the “extent of
reflexion of the spermiducal gland” (= glandular atrium) which can be best explained
as a preparation artifact rather than actual variability. The triangular jaws
in specimens from Virginia do not extend laterally as far as those from Tennessee
(Fig. 1D—E). The male genitalia ranges from almost completely filling segment
6 in the type description to filling about half of segment 6 (Fig. 1G); component
organs vary proportionately in size. The bursa varies from ovoid to pyriform.
Apparent variations in the length of the spermatheca are due to folding.
Microhabitat. On the cephalothorax.
Host. Cambarus bartonii bartonii Fabricius, C. tenebrosus.
Distribution. Overton and Wilson counties, TN; Augusta, Rockingham, and
Shenandoah counties, VA.
Figure 1. Cambarincola bobbi. A. lateral view of a whole specimen (redrawn and modifi
ed from Holt, 1988), scale bar = 0.2 mm; B. dorsal view of Tennessee specimen, scale
bar = 0.2 mm; C. ventral view of peristomium, scale bar = 40 μm; D. oblique view of
jaws, teeth shown as they appear on pharyngeal surface (dorsal over lower jaw, teeth
pointing posteriorly, USNM 99584), bar = 20 μm; E. dorso-ventral and F. lateral views of
jaws in Tennessee specimens, scale bar = 20 μm; G. dorsal view of spermatheca and male
genitalia in the left sides of segments 5 and 6, respectively (b = bursa; eb = ental bulb;
ga = glandular atrium; ma = muscular atrium; pg = prostate gland; sb = spermathecal
bulb; sd = spermathecal duct), scale bar = 40 μm.
202 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
Note. The gut contents in the NMNH specimens included diatom frustules and
small amounts of detritus. In addition to debris already noted, specimens from
Tennessee contained clay and silt particles, an oligochaete, head of a chironomid
larva, and fibers that appeared to be muscles due to their birefringence.
Justification for accepting variations. Dorsal ridges and supernumary muscles
are absent from the material examined by Holt (1988) (Fig. 1A). As Holt
routinely preserved specimens in 70% ethanol with formalin (Holt 1960:169),
the appearance of raised major annuli or ridges in our Tennessee specimens
(Fig. 1B) is likely to have been caused by general body contraction due to
preservation in 100% ethanol. The peristomium consists of four lobes on the
dorsal lip, a median emargination on the ventral lip, and two pairs of small lateral
lobes; the latter are not always easy to resolve (Fig. 1C). Holt (1988:795)
recorded only four dorsal lobes with some distortion that caused the ventral lip
to appear to have two lobes. Details on the jaws were limited to a lateral view
(Fig. 1D of Holt 1988), and a dental formula of 5/5. The shape of the jaws was
revealed to be triangular only after examination of a paratype (USNM 101500)
and other specimens (USNM 99584) prepared by Holt (Fig. 1D; S.R. Gelder,
pers. observ.). These data are consistent with additional details provided in
Figure 1E–F. The male genitalia in the type description were shown (Fig. 1B
of Holt 1988) as nearly filling the lateral area of segment 6. Although such an
aspect was observed in one of the Tennessee specimens, two others appeared
to fill only half the segment (Fig. 1G), with the component organs being of
proportional size. A similar size difference was used to justify the separation
of Cambarincola osceola Hoffman from Cambarincola vitreus Ellis (Hoffman
1963). However, this view has subsequently been considered questionable, and
it has been proposed that C. osceola and C. vitreus are conspecific (Holt and
Opell 1993:265). The length of the glandular atrium of C. bobbi varies from
1.0x segmental diameter to 0.6x and is directly related to the size of the male
genitalia. Holt (1988:794) described the bursa as oval and the penial sheath as
occupying its ental half. Our specimens show a pyriform bursa with a slightly
shorter ental penial sheath of 0.3x to 0.4x the bursa’s length. The penis was
described as “membranous” (Holt 1988), further elaborated as “distinctly
less muscular … with a few strands (? muscular)”, but Fig. 1C of Holt (1988)
did not include actual details. In the Tennessee specimens, the penis was observed
to be subspherical, composed of a few interstitial spaces between fibers
parallel to the central penial duct, rather than the usual dense, conical Cambarincola
arrangement. Whether the subspherical penis allows the internal fibers
to separate rather than being compressed into a conical configuration is not
known; our observations agree with the above quoted statement made by Holt.
All reports of the relative length of the spermatheca are consistent; however,
the duct was not as thick nor the bulb as large in the Tennessee specimens relative
to what was reported in the type description. The thickness of the duct can
be explained by contraction caused by the preserving ethanol, whereas the bulb
varies with the volume of sperm it contains (Fig. 2G). As a result of all of the
above factors, the preceding brief description was emended from Holt (1988).
2011 B.W. Williams and S.R. Gelder 203
Initially, Holt recognized a spherical penis with fibers and interstitial spaces
which led him to tentatively label three slides with multiple specimens, “Oedipodrilus
bobbi”. Unfortunately the label names were not replaced by the subsequent
and different published name, and have since become part of the NMNH catalog
(USNM 99560, 99584, 99595). Therefore, this name is considered nomina nuda
(ITZN 1999:glossary p. 111); a Latin term for “names without a description.”
As a result, it does not represent a valid species. The USNM specimens were
collected from Augusta and Rockingham counties, VA, despite an inadvertent
statement that C. bobbi was only known from the type locality in Shenandoah
County, VA (Holt 1988).
Pterodrilus robinae, new species (Fig. 2A–D)
Type specimens. The holotype (NBM-007151) and three paratypes (NBM-
007152, NBM-007153, NBM-007154) were deposited in the New Brunswick
Museum, Saint John, NB, Canada; three additional paratypes were retained
by the authors. Specimens were obtained from Orconectes durelli taken from
Sevenmile Creek in the Mill Creek system of the Cumberland River Watershed
(N36.09118, W086.71908) on the property of Ms. Robin M. Evans by David Ian
Withers on 5 May 2010, and David Ian Withers and Hannah Sophia Withers on
16 May 2010.
Diagnosis. Length about 0.73 mm, head width slightly wider than segment 1,
body slim pyriform, segments distinct, prominent transverse ridges segments 3
through 8, one pair unbranched digitiform appendages segments 4 and 5, five unbranched
appendages segment 8, supernumery muscles present; dorsal lip smooth,
lateral lobes absent, ventral lip median emargination; oral papillae present; jaws
small, subrectangular, teeth small, dental formula 3/2; pharyngeal sulci one pair;
glandular atrium ovoid, length 0.5x segmental diameter, deferent lobes absent;
Figure 2. Pterodrilus robinae new species. A. drawing of the holotype, scale bar = 0.1
mm; B. ventral view of the jaws, dorsal over ventral, with teeth pointing posteriorly
from a paratype; scale bar = 16 μm; C. male reproductive system in segment 6 (left) and
spermatheca in segment 5 (right) in the holotype, with a double-headed arrow showing
the observed variation in the start of the differentiated (vacuolar) epithelial cells
of the prostate gland in the type series (organs as labeled in Fig. 1), scale bar = 30 μm;
D. spermatheca in a paratype showing a thickened duct and enlarged bulb compared to
that in the holotype; same scale as C.
204 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
prostate arising third from ectal end, terminates subterminal, differentiated, ental
bulb absent; muscular atrium slim terete, length 0.2x segment diameter; bursa pyriform,
length 0.6x segment diameter, penial sheath ental third, penis cone-shaped,
protrusible; spermatheca length 1.2x segment diameter, duct tubular, length 0.6x
organ, bulb tubular, length 3x organ, ental process 0.1.
Etymology. Named for Ms. Robin M. Evans, who kindly granted permission
to collect crayfish on her property. The species epithet is derived from Robin
according to the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature (ICZN) ( ITZN
Description. The anterior nephridial pore opens dorso-medially on body segment
3, the vasa deferentia enter the glandular atrium entally, and the prostate
gland arises from the ectal third of the glandular atrium; all three characters
confirm the species as a member of the genus Pterodrilus. Seven fixed adult
specimens averaged 0.73 mm in length, ranging from 0.58 to 0.83 mm long. Live
specimens measured approximately 1.1 mm in length. The head is slightly wider
than segment 1 and distinct from the slim pyriform body. Segments 3 through 8
have prominent transverse ridges across the dorsal and lateral surfaces, and all
ridges contain supernumary muscles. Segments 4 and 5 each support one pair
of dorsal unbranched, digitiform appendages separated medially. Segment 8
displays a pronounced dorso-lateral ridge on which five unbranched digitiform
dorsal appendages appear in a fan-like arrangement (Fig. 2A).
The peristomium consists of a dorsal lip with a smooth margin, no lateral lobes,
and a ventral lip with a median emargination. Oral papillae surround the mouth.
The jaws are small, with a width less than 0.2x the head’s diameter, and with
the dorsal slightly larger than the ventral. Both jaws are subrectangular, slightly
concaved with sharply pointed teeth and a dental formula of 3/2 (Fig. 2B). The
lateral margins of each jaw have a “shoulder” where an additional tooth would be
expected. However no specimens were found with a dental formula of 5/4, and
there was no evidence that a lateral tooth had fractured from the jaw base. The
pharynx has one pair of sulci.
The male reproductive organs in segment 6 seen from the lateral aspect extend
across most of the segment (Fig. 2C). The glandular atrium is ovoid to sacculate
and with a length of approximately 0.6x the diameter of the segment. The prostate
gland is tubular, arises from the ectal third of the glandular atrium, then ends
approximately terminal to it. The prostate gland is lined with highly vacuolated
or “differentiated” cells. However, in two of the seven specimens examined,
differentiated cells started about 0.2x in from the ectal end of the prostate gland
as shown in Figure 3 with a double-headed arrow. An ental bulb is absent. The
muscular atrium is terete, with a length of 0.3x segment diameter. The bursa is
pyriform and about 0.6x the segment diameter in length. The ental third of the
bursa forms the penial sheath, which surrounds the conical, protrusible penis.
The spermatheca in segment 5 has a length approximately 1.2x that of the
segment’s diameter. The duct is 0.6x the total length of the organ, with the bulb
varying from tubular to subspherical and 0.3x in length (Fig. 2C–D). An ental
process is present.
2011 B.W. Williams and S.R. Gelder 205
Variations. The only observed variations are in the start of the differentiated
cells in the prostate gland and the shape of the spermathecal bulb, which is a
reflection of the amount of sperm held in the organ.
Microhabitat. Specimens were observed on the cephalothorax region and chelae.
Individuals appeared to prefer clefts and depressions along the edge of the
carapace and joints at the base of the chelae.
Distribution. Specimens known only from the type location.
Host. Orconectes durelli.
Other branchiobdellidans on the host. Cambarincola philadelphicus
Justification of the new species. Pterodrilus robinae differs from all other
species in the genus with its dental formula of 3/2 rather than 5/4. As a result, a
dental formula of 5/4 (Gelder 1996a) is no longer a generic character. Five digitiform
appendages on the dorso-lateral ridge of segment 8 are common to five
species: Pterodrilus robinae, Pterodrilus distichus Moore, P. mexicanus Ellis,
P. cedrus Holt, and P. hobbsi Holt. However, P. robinae and P. distichus are the
only species with pairs of unbranched dorsal digitiform appendages anterior to
segment 8; while these appendages extend from segments 2 to 7 on P. distichus
(Fig. 3A), they are restricted to segments 4 and 5 on the new species (Fig. 2A,
3B). Relative lengths of the various male organs are used extensively in defining
branchiobdellidan species. In P. distichus, the prostate gland ends subterminal to
the glandular atrium, while in P. robinae the ental tips of both glands end equally.
When viewed in lateral aspect, the male genitalia of P. robinae nearly fill segment
6, whereas only about half the segment is filled in P. distichus.
Remarks. The dorsal ridges and supernumary muscles are not easy to see when
live specimens extend themselves or when preserved specimens curl. All of the
specimens collected had large amounts of detritus with a few ciliates adhering to
their dorsal and lateral surfaces. One ciliate is attached to the dorsal surface of
segment 4 on the holotype and was initially thought to be one of the dorsal digitiform
appendages. The detritus had the same composition as that on the surface
of the crayfish host and consisted of a mixture of clay particles, live diatoms, and
unidentifiable organic-appearing material. The external debris on the branchiobdellidans
did not interfere with locomotion. Observations of gut contents showed
that the branchiobdellidans had ingested the detritus already described, but in
varying amounts and composition. Differences in the observed detrital composition
in the gut were likely a result of digestion, with only indigestible residues
remaining as visible components.
Identification and distribution of selected Pterodrilus species
Excluding monotypic genera in North America, Ceratodrilus and Pterodrilus
are unique in that their species can be identified using only external
characters. Pterodrilus species identifications are based on presence or absence
of dorsal segmental ridges caused by supernumerary muscles, and the presence
and sequence of dorsal segmental appendages or their absence. Species
descriptions are based on preserved specimens where the ridges are enhanced
due to the contraction of underlying muscles. Therefore, while the ridges are
206 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
still visible in live specimens, they are not as obvious. Consequently, the five
Pterodrilus species anticipated in the Cumberland River Watershed are illustrated
in Figure 3, with the addition of the new species described during the
present study. Digitiform appendages on segments 2 to 7 are found on P. distichus
(Fig. 3A), but only on segments 4 and 5 on P. robinae (Fig. 3B). Dorsal
appendages are absent in P. annulatus Gelder and P. choritonamus Holt, with
dorsal ridges prominent on segments 2 to 7 in the former (Fig. 3C) and absent
in the latter species (Fig. 3E). The five digitiform appendages on the segment
8 ridge of P. cedrus (Fig. 3D) may be partially obscured or folded, resulting in
specimens being misidentified as P. choritonamus. The five appendages on segment
8 in P. hobbsi are fan-like (Fig. 3F), but often appear more digitiform and
similar to the segment 8 appendages of P. cedrus. Consequently, it is important
to establish the presence or absence of dorsal ridges as a secondary character to
distinguish between the two species; if ridges are found, the specimen is P. cedrus,
whereas it is P. hobbsi if dorsal ridges are absent.
The new species, P. robinae, was found only at a single location, although
there is every reason to expect a wider distribution as additional sites are
sampled. The genus Pterodrilus is relatively widespread, ranging from New
York State and Michigan into northern Georgia. The most widespread species is
P. distichus, extending from the northernmost edge of the pterodrilid distribution
to Kentucky, with the remaining species forming generally separate groups from
Arkansas-Missouri to the Appalachian Mountains in Virginia–North Carolina
and Georgia. In a restricted review of mid-Eastern States, Holt (1969) identifi
ed three species—P. alcicornus Moore, P. hobbsi, and P. simondsi Holt—in
Figure 3. Drawing of the dorso-lateral surfaces of the body segments of five species of
Pterodrilus: A. P. distichus, B. P. robinae, C. P. annulatus, D. P. cedrus, E. P. choritonamus,
and F. P. hobbsi; scale bar 0.2 mm (redrawn and modified from Gelder 1996b,
2011 B.W. Williams and S.R. Gelder 207
the Appalachian Mountains ranging from Kentucky–Virginia to Georgia–North
Carolina, and three species—P. cedrus, P. hobbsi, and P. choritonamus—in a
relatively small area around Overton County, TN. The presence of P. hobbsi in
two apparently disjunct areas indicates that it might be more widely distributed
than current records indicate. Pterodrilus cedrus was also recorded in Missouri
(Holt 1968), suggesting a distribution similar to that of P. annulatus, which has
also been reported in Missouri and central Tennessee (Gelder 1996a). Additional
pterodrilid diversity is also expected from the mid-eastern region of the USA.
The Tennessean P. robinae was compared to a limited description of an undescribed
species of Pterodrilus referred to in Holt (1968:32) from Union County,
GA and Cherokee County, NC. Significant differences indicate that Holt’s specimens
Observations on sympatry and distribution of branchiobdellidans
Only two branchiobdellidan species, C. philadelphicus and the newly described
P. robinae, were found on specimens of O. durelli from Sevenmile
Creek near Nashville. Cambarincola bobbi was the only branchiobdellidan
species found on Cambarus tenebrosus in an unnamed tributary to Cedar Creek
in Lebanon. In contrast, the species diversity observed among the four Overton
County collection sites totalled ten branchiobdellidan species from five genera,
although the number of branchiobdellidan species per host species and site
ranged from one to six. Two of the Overton County sites were located in Standing
Stone State Park (SSSP), namely Morgan Creek at the head of the southeast
arm of Standing Stone Lake and Mill Creek below the Standing Stone Lake dam
at the head of the northwest arm. An additional collection site in Mill Creek was
located 4 km southeast and upstream of the Park’s lake in Standing Stone State
Forest (SSSF). The fourth Overton County site in Flat Creek was approximately
14 km south of Standing Stone Lake and separate from the Park’s drainage.
Cambarincola bobbi was found at Mill Creek in SSSF on Cambarus tenebrosus
and at Flat Creek on C. tenebrosus and C. graysoni. Branchiobdellidan species
found in sympatry with Cambarincola bobbi were, respectively, Ankyrodrilus
legaeus Holt, P. choritonamus, Bdellodrilus illuminatus (Moore) and Xironodrilus
formosus Ellis at Mill Creek; Ankyrodrilus koronaeus Holt, A. legaeus,
Cambarincola holti Hoffman, P. cedrus, and P. hobbsi on Cambarus tenebrosus
hosts at Flat Creek; and A. legaeus, Cambarincola branchiophilus Holt,
C. holti, and P. cedrus on Cambarus graysoni hosts at Flat Creek. Orconectes
placidus specimens were collected from three sites and carried P. cedrus,
P. hobbsi, and X. formosus at Morgan Creek; P. cedrus at Mill Creek below the
dam; and A. legaeus and P. cedrus at Flat Creek.
If the collection from the Cedar Creek tributary near Lebanon is ignored, a
lower diversity of branchiobdellidans was observed on Orconectes hosts, ranging
from one to three, relative to the four to six branchiobdellidan species found on
Cambarus hosts examined during this study. However, the Lebanon collection
with one branchiobdellidan species on C. tenebrosus illustrates that ectosymbiont
sympatry is complex and a result of many factors.
208 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
The occurrence of branchiobdellidan species reported in our Overton County
collections present interesting qualitative results which are independent of the
host’s genus. Four species, A. koronaeus, B. illuminatus, C. branchiophilus, and
P. choritonamus, were only observed at a single site and on a single host. None of
these species are limited in distribution to the collection area. Indeed, the known
range of B. illuminatus extends from New Brunswick, Canada to Alabama, USA.
In contrast to our single host and site observations, P. cedrus was found on all
hosts at three of the four sampled sites, and A. legaeus occurred on all host species
examined from Flat Creek and Mill Creek (SSSF). Both P. cedrus and A. legaeus
are endemic to the mid-eastern region of the USA. Similar observations on ectosymbiont-
host diversity, including B. illuminatus on four different host crayfish,
were reported from the Mountain Lake region, VA, by Hobbs et al. (1967). These
data refute the idea of wide-spread host-specificity as periodically suggested
(Brown and Creed 2004, McManus 1960). The assertion of host-specificity also
ignores the successful adoption of exotic crayfish by native branchiobdellidans
in Europe (Ďuriš et al. 2006, Gelder 2006). The most unusual host-branchiobdellidan
symbiosis reported to date involves Cambarincola mesochoreus Hoffman
and Cambarincola pamelae Holt, usually found on Procambarus clarkii Girard,
adopting Callinectes sapidus Rathbun (Blue Crab) as hosts in estuarine habitats
in the southeastern USA (Overstreet 1983) and Chesapeake Bay, MD (Gelder and
The distribution of branchiobdellidan species in North America (Gelder et
al. 2002) is a result of both general sampling, like Perry C. Holt’s circum-USA
journey (P.C. Holt, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg,
VA, pers. comm.), as well as collections within more restricted or disjunct
areas. The discovery of C. holti in Overton County, TN (Gelder 1996b) showed
that the species was not restricted to its type location in Kentucky as previously
thought. Similarly, prior to this study, C. bobbi was only known from a restricted
area of northern Virginia. As additional studies are conducted, the distribution
of branchiobdellidan species will be further emended and the extent of species
sympatry better understood.
The authors thank David Ian Withers and Hannah Sophia Withers for their supply of
crayfish, and Ms. Robin M. Evans for permission to collect on her property. We are grateful
for support from the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation - Natural
Heritage Program, Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency, and the Tennessee Department
of Agriculture, Forestry Division, for providing permission to collect crayfish, and for the
help and hospitality while at Standing Stone State Park. We would also like to extend great
appreciation to Dr. and Mrs. Ralph O. Brinkhurst for their support and generosity.
Brinkhurst, R.O., and S.R. Gelder. 2001. Annelida: Oligochaeta and Branchiobdellida.
Pp. 431–463, In J.H. Thorpe and F. Covitch (Eds.). Ecology and Classification of
North American Freshwater Invertebrates. 2nd Edition. Academic Press, New York,
NY. 1056 pp.
2011 B.W. Williams and S.R. Gelder 209
Brown, B.L., and R.P. Creed, Jr. 2004. Host preference by an aquatic ectosymbiotic
annelid on 2 sympatric species of host crayfishes. Journal of the North American
Benthological Society 23:90–100.
Ďuriš, Z., I. Horká, J. Kristian, and P. Kozák. 2006. Some cases of macro-epibiosis on
the invasive crayifish Orconectes limosus in the Czech Republic. Bulletin Français de
la Pêche et de la Pisciculture 380–381:1325–1337.
Gelder, S.R. 1996a. Description of a new branchiobdellidan species, with observations
on three other species, and a key to the genus Pterodrilus (Annelida: Clitellata). Proceedings
of the Biological Society of Washington 109:256–263.
Gelder, S.R. 1996b. Histochemical characterization of secretions in the male reproductive
system of two species of branchiobdellidans (Annelida: Clitellata): A new character
for the phylogenetic matrix? Hydrobiologia 334:219–227.
Gelder, S.R. 1999. Zoogeography of branchiobdellidans (Annelida) and temnocephalidans
(Platyhelminthes) ectosymbiotic on freshwater crustaceans, and their reactions
to one another in vitro. Hydrobiologia 406:21–31.
Gelder, S.R. 2006. Branchiobdellidans, Pp. 148–149, In C. Souty-Grosset, D.M. Holdich,
P.Y. Noël, J.D. Reynolds, and P. Haffner (Eds.). Atlas of Crayfish in Europe. Muséum
National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris, France (Patrimoines Naturels, 64). 188 pp.
Gelder, S.R., and G. Messick. 2006. First report of the aberrant association of branchiobdellidans
(Annelida: Clitellata) on blue crabs (Crustacea: Decapoda) in the Chesapeake
Bay, Maryland, USA. Invertebrate Biology 125:51–55.
Gelder, S.R., N.L. Gagnon, and K. Nelson. 2002. Taxonomic considerations and distribution
of the Branchiobdellida (Annelida: Clitellata) on the North American continent.
Northeastern Naturalist 9:451–468.
Govedich F.R., B.A. Bain, W.E. Moser, S.R. Gelder, R.W. Davies, and R.O. Brinkhurst.
2010. Annelida (Clitellata): Oligochaeta, Branchiobdellida, Hirudinida, and Acanthodbdellida.
Pp. 385–436, In J.H. Thorp and A.P. Covich (Eds.). Ecology and Classifi
cation of North American Freshwater Invertebrates. Academic Press - Elsevier,
New York, NY. 1056 pp.
Hobbs, H.H. Jr., P.C. Holt, and M. Walton. 1967. The crayfishes and their epizootic ostracod
and branchiobdellid associates of the Mountain Lake, Virginia, region. Proceedings
of the United States National Museum 123:1–84.
Hoffman, R.L. 1963. A revision of the North American annelid worms of the genus
Cambarincola (Oligochaeta: Branchiobdellidae). Proceedings of the United States
National Museum 114:271–371.
Holt, P.C. 1960. On a new genus of the family Branchiobdellidae (Oligochaeta). American
Midland Naturalist 64:169–176.
Holt, P.C. 1968. The genus Pterodrilus (Annelida: Branchiobdellida). Proceedings of the
United States National Museum 125:1–44.
Holt, P.C. 1969. The relationship of the branchiobdellid fauna of the southern Appalachians.
Pp. 191–219, In P.C. Holt (Ed.). The Distributional History of the Biota of the
Southern Appalachians. Part I: Invertebrates. Research Division Monograph, Virginia
Polytechnic Institute, [PROVIDE CITY], VA. 295 pp.
Holt, P.C. 1973. Branchiobdellids (Annelida: Clitellata) from some eastern North American
caves, with descriptions of new species of the genus Cambarincola. International
Journal of Speleology 5:219–255.
Holt, P.C. 1988. Four new species of cambarincolids (Clitellata: Branchiobdellida) from
the southeastern United States with a redescription of Oedipodrilus macbaini (Holt,
1955). Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 101:794–808.
210 Southeastern Naturalist Vol. 10, No. 2
Holt, P.C., and B.D. Opell. 1993. A checklist of and illustrated key to the genera and species
of the Central and North American Cambarincolidae (Clitellata: Branchiobdellida).
Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington 106:251–295.
International Trust for Zoological Nomenclature (ITZN). 1999. International Code of
Zoological Nomenclature. Natural History Museum, London, UK. 306 pp.
McManus, L.R. 1960. Some ecological studies of the Branchiobdellidae (Oligochaeta).
Transactions of the American Microscopical Society 79:420–428.
Overstreet, R.M. 1983. Metazoan Symbionts of Crustaceans. Pp. 155–250, In A.J.
Provenzano Jr. (Ed.). The Biology of Crustacea. Vol. 6: Pathobiology. Academic
Press, New York, NY. 248 pp.